We planned to do Advanced course with BICD, but due to a serie of bad luck and unfortunate events (ATM stealing our cash, none of our cards working, my husband's ear squeeze and more), we could only do a couple of fun dives with them. Still, we'd definitely recommend them, we saw and talked to all the dive shops on Utila and BICD has BY FAR the nicest accommodation included in the price of diving (what most of the schools offer is really just for tough backpackers), their equipment is super new, the boat is a proper diving boat (not a small fishing boat like in other cases) with enough space. And more importantly, the staff is nice, the instructors Nick and Fernanda were both professional, knowledgeable and patient with our beginners' questions. The manager, Rebecca, was more than helpful in our troubles, I can't thank her enough.
Walk around, talk to the people in the shops and see what suits you best, but BICD should definitely be one of your top choices.
If you own or manage Bay Islands College of Diving, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.