My partner and I, along with another couple, just spent two weeks at De Real Macaw and loved it.
It was our 3rd time on the island and the 3rd place we have stayed.
This was easily the best of the bunch!
The location is wonderful (close to the split and "downtown". The view is great and Jesse and Peter (the owners) are extremely helpful but also very laid back.
THe rooms were clean and in good shape.
We are planning to stay here again our next time on Caye Caulker!