We've been to Caye Caulker at least 5 or 6 times, and always stay here. Room 12 is the best one, on the second floor by the ocean. The island does seem to be getting more Americanized each time we go (more rap music, for starters), and the locals aren't too thrilled with the cruise ships coming in. However, it is much quieter than Ambergris, and still has the same options for diving, snorkeling, or going inland. This is the only place on the island I'd stay. We even got married on the beach here, so Jim and Mario (the owners) can arrange anything!