I've seen a few negative reviews about this place and I can only conclude that the people that wrote them aren't the Pedro's Inn type person. If you are looking for a place where they shower you bed with lilac pedals and there's a majestic waterfall overlooking an infinity pool and the gentle noise of the water breaking on the shore is your alarm clock, and you're insulated from everything, then skip Pedro's. Sure that's nice if you're on a honeymoon or are loaded with cash, but that's not most of us.
But if you're looking for a place that won't cost you you're whole vacation budget, serves a nice cold beer and is a gathering spot from everyone from bookies to retired engineers to wayward Canadian oilfield workers, then Pedro's is your place.
I recently spent two weeks in San Pedro, and didn't regret staying at Pedro's once. My room was cleaned daily with fresh towels. The location was just a quick walk to town, the grocery store, and Ramon's resort, which has the best stretch of beach in town and great chairs and hammocks to lounge in.
The staff at Pedro's was friendly and helpful. Cindy will help you out if you want to book any day trips or just need advice on a good bar or place to grab a bite. The bartenders there are great. And they aren't you're run-of-the-mill resort bartenders who give you fake smiles and kiss your a$$. They're real. They're sharp. They'll joke with you. They'll give you a hard time when you deserve it. Reminded me of my bartenders at home, which was nice.
For the people who complained about Peter (Pedro) being rude, you need to relax. Peter is sharp tongued, witty and honest Englishman. He speaks his mind. But he's a great guy to talk to. Will buy you a shot of Jager upon your arrival and always has a great story to tell.
Overall that's what makes Pedro's the place to stay. I went down to San Pedro by myself, not knowing anyone down there. But each night I met someone new and fun at Pedro's and would find someone to drink with, watch the game on TV or play Wii. And they're real, genuine people. People who live there. People who know how to go out, drink and have a good time. Not the crowd of people who sip $10 pina colodas and spouting on about they're 3 week travel aboard a yatch in the South Pacific and they're manicured estate in Boca Raton.
If you're looking for that picture perfect Carribean vacation where your every whim is catered to, don't go to Pedro's. But if you're the type person who enjoys waking up with half his clothes on, a purple right pinkie toe that you suspect you smashed on a rock on your 2 am walk home and meeting people who have something to talk about other than their stock portfolios, then there's no other place to be other than Pedro's.