2nd time to the island and we missed it the first time due to a power outage (ended up at the City Pier Restaurant down the road). We were told to eat downstairs with the locals. Had fun watching everyone fish and saw dolphins come in close. I had a grouper sandwich and my husband had a burger. Also had an appetizer of stuffed jalapenos. They were very good, Husband's burger was good and my grouper sandwich was good but maybe not as good as I was expecting. I probably would have been happier trying one of the specials. I would still recommend this place for the casual atmosphere and local flavor.
If you own or manage Rod & Reel Pier, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.