We had cocktails in the bar while we waited for a table. My margarita was delicious I could have had several! We sat outside on the water side which had to be the best table in all of Avalon. You are right over the water overlooking the harbor. It really is a fantastic location for afternoon cocktails and dinner. The food was average by mainland standards but really good by Avalon standards since we've yet to find a really good restaurant on the island. We actually went 2 days in a row. Fried calamari and artichoke apps were really great. The sauce on the seafood pappardelle was watery. Would have been perfect if they simmered the sauce down to intensify the flavor, or maybe drained the pasta more.
Service was great, friendly accommodating staff.
If you own or manage Bluewater Avalon Seafood Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.