Went to Catalina this week on a whim and found the Limited Offer Package at this hotel. The website said rates started at $100 per person. Seemed like a good deal (included the boat trip from Pedro, a glass bottom boat trip, and one night). I think it ended up being $109 per person once tax was added.
The room was smaller than most I'm used to, but it was nice and clean. The staff was super friendly, and once I found out how much the boat ride was if I bought it on my own (over $60) I started realizing how good a deal we got.
We went in the quiet season so there wasn't as much to do. But most of my complaints have to do with the tours/restaurants being closed (which I'll post on separately). The staff at the hotel was at least very helpful in recommending the things to do during this time of tthe year.
I think this is a great place to go to if you're looking for a quiet location. It's near everything and the staff is nice. The rooms a bit small, (apparently we had the cheapest room - could've had a larger room if we paid more). But overall, was a great stay! :)