First and foremost, the staff at Hotel Vista Del Mar are incredibly kind, polite and accommodating. Rooms are not guaranteed until 3pm but they have a free baggage check so you explore the island until your room is ready -- in our case, they called my cell and we were able to check in an hour and a half early.
We stayed in a Courtyard Deluxe room, which was spacious and clean. Our room (107) was next to a supply closet so there was the occasional bump or knock but nothing to complain about. If I have an issue it is the layout of the hotel is a bit strange. It's located on the 3rd floor and there is no elevator. Keep that in mind if you have a lot of luggage (or in my case, a very pregnant wife). Also, the rooms don't open to the outdoors, instead they all face a single semi-open air "courtyard." The courtyard roof is a skylight so you get plenty of natural light in what would otherwise be a large hallway.