My girlfriend and I spent four short nights at the resort and it was everything we hoped for. I spent a couple of months looking online where to go in St Thomas and could not have been happier with Secret Harbor. We stayed in building 4, which I have to recommend due to its slightly elevated position which allows for amazing views, and a little privacy, while still being right on the beach. The restaurant was top notch! the service was impeccable, and the food was delicious. We arrived 10/12/12 and left 10/16, there was one tropical storm that just missed us to the north, but caused a little storm activity but for the most part it was mostly sunny with the occasional fast traveling group of clouds that gave some welcome shade. We want to return in the spring to stay longer and partake of more snorkeling, shopping, lounging,.. ect.

We were celebrating our 25 yr anniversary. We had a great time on the Virgin Islands, We were a little concerned beforehand about Secret Harbour because of some negatives reviews, but we had a very nice experience there. We stayed on the hillside condo unit (#621) and had an awesome view of Nazareth Bay and the sunset. We enjoyed snorkeling here, it is among the best on the island. Also, they have a Dive shop and went out on two boat dives. (The dive boat team were great!) The room had a full kitchen and we got some groceries and enjoyed some meals from our balcony. (Choose 'Food Center' over Marina Market for better price/selection) The resturant has servers out on the beach, getting you food (very tasty) and drink brought to your lounge chair. Very Nice. The location is great as we went to St John & BVI out of nearby Redhook ferry. Can't wait to return to the Virgin Islands and Secret Harbour.

We stayed in a beachfront 1 bedroom suite. The room was spacious, clean, had a nice view. Bathroom could have used a little updating. Kitchen was fine. Pool is not oceanside, so didn't use it. The Snorkeling off the resort was probably some of the best on the island (without a boatride that is); Close to town. Resort bar and restaurant were good. Staff was enjoyable. One day we did not have room service.

We stayed at a beachfront 1-bedroom condo in building#3 - great view, comfortable accommodations with deck view of harbour, but - and this is my fault for not complaining right away to management - the shower only delivered cool water during most of our brief stay. We were too busy having fun to go register a complaint! (and the water heater was replaced the day after I complained). Secret Harbour's grounds are lovely and well maintained, service is great, there was none of the beach chair reservation issue I've seen at other resorts, the food in the restaurant was exceptional (although a bit pricey) and the bar food is good too. The full kitchen in the beach front condo allowed us to balance this by eating some meals in. And there is good (not great) snorkeling right off the beach.
Advice:
(1) Bring or buy some bug repellant - I have extremely itchy bites all over from the no-see-ums.
(2) After pricing this resort as a package (airfare+room) I then compared buying airfare from airline and calling Secret Harbour directly for a room price - and I got a much better deal this way (saved almost $500). Maybe this was because we traveled in early December when there are fewer travelers (so better deals) but the comparison is probably worth your time.
(3) Do your own arithmetic about rental cars vs. cabs. We took cabs the few times we wanted to go to Red Hook (for shopping, for dinner, to take the ferry to BVI) because our vacation was more about chilling out at a lovely place than driving around. If we'd rented a car for the week, we would have spent +$300 instead we spent less than half that (about $130) in cab fares - IMO a better way to support the local economy.
(4) We purchased some food at the Marina Market in Red Hook - for selection/price we should probably have gone to Food Center instead.