Staying the the Motel above the restaurant ideally placed for us, liked the menu so booked a few hours in advance, glad we did place got packed. My wife and I shared two platters (for 1) a seafood platter and a special, the special also had a variety of seafood though generally different to what was on the seafood platter, for example both had raw oysters but the special they were in vodka and wasabi (I thnk) were the seafood platter they were natural. We ordered an excellent bottle of Pinot Noir to go with it (I know red wine with seafood), which was well priced at around $35. The service was fast freindly and effiecient though we never felt rushed which is a big thing with me.
Great meal, great price, good sevice would highly recommend.
If you own or manage Watermill Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.