I spent one night in this hotel when I travelled to Perth for business. I had asked to be booked in at Rydges but someone at work decided to save a buck and put me here instead, as it's only a few steps away.
I have to say that the location is absolutely fantastic, but the hotel is not up to the standard of other Holiday Inns I've stayed in. For some reason I was given a set of two rooms, a double and a single, and was instructed not to use the double room but walk through it to the single. The bathroom was attached to the double room, though, so it was an odd and inconvenient arrangement.
The decor was old and pretty ugly, though it seemed clean. The bed is not uncomfortable, but again, not new and pretty ordinary. Good TV with some cable channels, and the bathroom was also good, with a decent bath and surprisingly nice glycerin soap, as well as the usual amenities. One thing I really like about the Holiday Inn chain is that if you forget something basic like a comb or toothbrush they will provide you with one for free. I didn't have to use that this time, but it was nice to be reminded of it after a recent stay at the Melbourne Stamford where I was charged $5 for a toothbrush that had very clearly been used before (and "sanitised"). There was no mini-bar or fridge in the room, though there were bottles of water on the nightstands for about $5 each.
Check in was reasonably quick and easy, though this might have been luck of the draw, as there is only one attendant at a tiny counter and if there was a queue you could be waiting a while. Check out was a bit of a drama with Reception insisting that the room had not been paid for. I telephoned my office which assured me that it had been paid for. The receptionist would not budge and as I had a plane to catch I paid for the room again. On the way to the airport in a cab I received a call apologising for the error and confirming that the room had been paid for after all. Not impressed. Also, while there was no assistance with porterage etc, a concierge did assist me in flagging the cab.
Room service is not great. There is a limited (hours and range) and expensive selection of meals delivered from the restaurant downstairs, or a similarly limited selection of inexpensive meals delivered in takeaway boxes. I opted for one of the latter (chicken and rice) and it was a generous serve but not particularly interesting and a bit dry. I'd prefer a more conventional selection of meals or snacks at a higher price but available around the clock. Also it would have been nice to have a plate and proper cutlery to eat with.
The hotel's saving grace is the fantastic location. It is right on the Hay Street mall, in the middle of the CBD, five minutes walk from any office you might need to visit (in my case, a government department, a law firm and a tribunal), right across the road from His Majesty's Theatre (where I managed to get a cheap ticket to La Traviata), and also right across the road from a stop for the Perth tour bus which I practically lived on the last time I visited (for $25 a day this bus stops pretty much anywhere you might have been thinking of going in Perth, including the Burswood casino and the discount outlet shopping centre). Also, when I say "five minutes walk", I don't mean a fit young backpacker in Birkenstocks five-minutes walk, no siree, I mean a fat, tired, lazy middle-aged lawyer in a hot suit and high heels with a heavy briefcase five minutes walk. And when I say "across the road", it's a mall, so I really mean about eight steps. It could not be more convenient.
I did not stop for breakfast, but probably wouldn't have had it at the hotel - there are several cafes serving inexpensive breakfasts right on the doorstep. And there's a great bookshop, Elizabeth's, a few doors down the road which seems to be open quite late at night - I was able to browse while waiting for the queue at the theatre to subside.
Overall this is a pretty no-frills operation, but the price suggests a nicer hotel, along the lines of other Holiday Inns. I'm giving it an extra point for the fantastic location; otherwise it would be a solid two. I wouldn't kvetch too badly if I wound up here again,so long as it was just a night, but next time I think I'll try Rydges after all.