Three girlfriends and I stayed for 3 nights and loved it. Loved sitting by the fire for a drink. Loved the bar. Loved the hospitality that included complimentary drinks on the owner, recommendations for restaurants and bars, chairs being arranged for us by the fire - even jelly beans laid out for us when they realised we loved them! The location is perfect. Just off Toorak Rd and round the corner from Chapell St. Wonderful neighbourhood cafes. The hotel itself was great for us. The room was adequately sized, quiet with space for all our gear. The Spa was a real treat - highly recommend it. Overall, definitely my first choice of somewhere to stay on a return trip to Melbourne.