We stayed 2 nights at The Blackman for our wedding anniversary.
A really nice, modern hotel just off St Kilda Road with a tram stop outside - convenient! Comfortable bed, thick pillows, Blackmans on the walls, good sized room and bathroom, kitchenette and a small balcony. The heating worked (a necessity in Melbourne in the winter!).
The cafe off the lobby serves good breakfasts, everything from fresh pastries through to cooked delights - not a buffet in sight!!!
Friendly, helpful staff added to the experience.