I spent January 9th aboard Seastar. I choose Seastar becuase of the reviews on tripadvisor and I am very happy I did. What I liked about it was the small boat atmosphere. They had a ton of staff (all extremely friendly) on the boat and I felt very well taken care of. We visited 2 amaing Reef's during the day and had plenty of time at each. The best part is they take photos during the day and then post them to Facebook at night. They don't charge you for the photos - unheard of these days. What a great bonus.
The only con is for someone who doesn't like choppy waters or small boats this is not your boat. But I had not problems on the boat at all.
If you own or manage Seastar Cruises Reef Day Trips, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.