You will pay for the experience. There are many better meals on Anguilla for less money (see Veya). We ordered two lobsters. They were split in half and grilled, both were very generous sizes. They were topped with a delicious sauce made in house, and a small side of pasta salad. The location is charming. The live music and rum punches make the experience more festive. And the owner brings his own island charm. But at $200 for two people, we may not return next time. There are plenty of lobsters on Anguilla for $50 and under.
If you own or manage Scilly Cay, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.