We booked for a week at PS3 for the last week in March 2007. I had researched accomodation in Playas de las Americas mainly using this site, and this seemed a popular and competitive accomodation. Many reviews outshine even the more "upmarket" 4 and 5 star hotels. Obviously I realise everyone's tastes and expectations are different, but I still thought this would be an excellent place considering the amount of reviews that had been written about it and all mainly good to excellent ones. As ever, the reader needs to take all these reviews as a guide only, so what may not be my cup of tea may be someone else's.
Overall we were disappointed with the accomodation. The holiday did not exactly get off to a flying start though. When we arrived we had to wait nearly 2 hours for our room to be ready - then when we got to it, it was on the top floor of the complex, facing the road side, but without even a terrace of any note. The only terrace we had was one overlooking the next block of the apartments, which were only a few metres away, directly looking into the windows of other bathrooms! Not good. The apartment itself was small and shabby and stunk of blocked drains - not to mention dingy and dark. Neither myself or my girlfriend were happy so we went to complain - we were told PS3 was full so we were offered an apartment in PS5 which is over the road.
PS5 in my opinion is streets ahead of PS3 in terms of the room standard - instead of our dingy attic room, we now had a 2 floor spacious apartment. Downstairs was a large living room and small kitchen, with a terrace and flat screen tv. Upstairs was a large bathroom and reasonable bedroom, with another terrace. However, it does not have a pool, although if you have legs and don't mind using them, a short trip over the road to PS3 or PS4 will solve that. Note that these apartments are built over a supermarket, so we could hear the hum of the freezer units or air con in the early hours.
PS3 itself is a bit of a mixed bag in my opinion. The reception staff were fine and we encountered no trouble with them. Hiring a car from reception was easy as they simply dialled the car rental firm and they came and picked us up and took us to their office to do the paperwork. However, the pool area is a bit of a let down to me. There are loads and loads of sunloungers. The trouble is you MUST get there early, by 9.30/10 if you are to stand a chance of getting one. Bear in mind we went off peak and the complex was full then. On our first day we went to get a sunbed at about 11.15 and despite their being a multitude of them, we could not find any spare. So forget about a lie in if you plan on lying round the pool early doors - although we did notice later on in the day lots of people were leaving around 2 to 3pm, so many became vacant then.
The other downside of the pool area (and of course this is all a matter of opinion) is that it reminded me of a beach full of seals lying around on each other. Parts of the pool area are incredibly crowded with sunbeds squeezed next to sunbeds, forming a bit of an eyesore and very little privacy/space. However, if you head towards the side areas of the pool there is a bit more space there so you can lie back and stretch out without smacking someone across the head. The pool, however, does look good and is very large so most people should be impressed by that. We ate at the pool restaurant in the mornings and the breakfasts, although not the greatest, seemed good value as you got tea/coffee and orange thrown in too.
We found that there were a lot of Dutch/Germans staying there and very few British. The majority of our fellow holiday makers were OAPs or young families, and unless these demographics change in the Summer time, then I wouldn't recommend it for young (ish) couples.
PS3 also lacked a really good bar - there is one on site, but when we popped in there it always seemed empty. I prefer to have a decent bar area to chill out in before going out at night and the complex lacked this (although there are that many bars around it isn't really a big problem).
So for me, PS3 is just ok. Maybe if we'd got a room with a pool or sea view, they would be better than the one we experienced.
We did spend a day at PS4 - on the day we couldnt get a sunbed at PS3. For my money, PS4 was a nicer place. It just seemed a little bit cleaner and tidier - and newer. The pool area was less cluttered and a bit more spacious than PS3 and there seemed to be less kids running about.
As for the area - I think the PS's are in an excellent location. There are some great restaurants in the area all of which were good value and offering good food. I think they must have spent a fair bit of money developing this area - other parts of the resort do look a bit shabby, but we felt this part was more "upmarket". The weather at this time of the year is also ok - it's hot when the sun is out, but quite cold when it's behind clouds. And there was quite a lot of cloud during our stay. People would be huddled in their towels around the pool at certain points, only to be unwrapping themselves when the sun came out again. It does get cold at night though!!
So overall, although many reviews give this place a 5/5, I'd be a bit more cautious and give it a 3. But of course, it all depends on your individual tastes and expectations.