We went here for a dinner during our honeymoon based on TripAdvisor reviews, and were not disappointed! The owner seated us in their quiet courtyard area, which is just below the cathedral though you'd never know it since it's so peaceful and shady. We were given plenty of time to make our choices, but ultimately let the waitstaff/owner recommend what we should order - and they did not disappoint! We had a cianghale with fresh fettucine (house made, it seemed) and another pasta with wonderful tender white fish and a tomato sauce. Great wine, a limoncello, and some bread to mop up the leftover sauce - va bene! Definitely worth seeking this place out for a quiet dinner.
If you own or manage Wine-dark house, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.