My wife and I visited Pulcino in October of this year. We had a fantastic meal, truffle and porcini pasta and the wine was very good. As other reviewers have stated this is a very large place however our service was very good the day we were there. There were very few guests the day we visited.
We enjoyed it so much we had wine, cheese, pasta, truffles and olive oil shipped home. We paid around $200 for shipping and expected to see the same kind of service we received in the restaurant in what we had shipped home. That was not the case. Our shipment arrived soaked in a broken bottle of wine, which ruined several bags of Pasta. On further inspection of the packaging it was easy to see why this had occurred. Extremely poor packing and it was actually amazing that additional bottles of wine weren't broken. As we've opened bottles of wine its clear that the shipment was exposed to extreme heat as each of the reserve bottles we've opened have been bad.
We've attempted to contact Pulcino to rectify the situation on several occasions but have not gotten a response in roughly 2 months since we've been home.
Moral of the story, enjoy it while you are there but forget about having anything shipped home.
If you own or manage Ristorante Pulcino a Montepulciano, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.