My wife and I stayed at Cap Maison from 17th- 26th October. It was the perfect honeymoon destination. The hotel looked beautiful , the room was plush (and cleaned to perfection each day), was quiet and secluded, it had a very good restaurant with great views, and the staff were incredibly helpful and friendly. It really was the staff that make this hotel so specia: from the people at front desk to ground staff, maintenance guys, waiters to bar staff - everyone went out of their way to make it a relaxing and enjoyable holiday for us.
There is only one restaurant at the hotel, so if you want to try something different then you'll need to jump in a taxi; the nearest main area, Rodney Bay, was about 10 minutes away (approx $15 USD each way).
Twice at the restaurant and once when checking out our bill was incorrect, but these issues were quickly and courteously dealt with.
As a honeymoon couple we received a complementary (and very enjoyable!) couples massage and a sunset cruise upon Cap Maison's yacht (one of the highlights of our stay). We were also given Champagne on arrival and a Champagne breakfast.
In summary, I can safely say this was the best hotel we've stayed at and want to thank the staff again for their hospitality.