Monday night was full and that says a lot out of season. The food was excellent quality and reasonably priced. Pub grub at its best, good quality ingredients freshly cooked. Good selection of beers too. The décor was very much aimed at diners rather than traditional pub-goers and unless you can sit outside you will be surrounded by eaters. That's what we went for anyway so it wasn't a problem for us.
Overall, I think on the basis of food and value for money I am surprised it doesn't rank much higher on tripadvisor. Perhaps the staff behind the bar could be more welcoming?
If you own or manage The Cottage Loaf, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.