Went there based on the good reviews on Tripadvisor and we did not regret it. The food was delicious and its size was huuuge (we had to take away the Kaiserschmarn because we could not finish it). Our waitress was very friendly, talkative and charming. I will go back when I am back to Salzburg, however, I will take a seat a bit further from the entrance in the non-smoking section because the smoke came in from the smoggy part (by the way, I do not understand why Austria has not yet joined the anti-smoking countries...).
If you own or manage Zum Guten Hirten, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.