We went here for the fish meze which has rave reviews on Tripadvisor.
First of all the welcome was friendly and efficient.
We started the Meze with a number of cold dishes which were the standard fare - octopus wasn't great just tasted of vinegar and crab sticks worried us that the fish meze may contain the best quality food.
We then started receiving the hot courses - sardines first which were nice but then down hill from there.
The squid was the toughest we had ever had, we couldn't even cut through it with the knife provided, then came what could be described as cheap party food, a prawn in filo, a prawn in breadcrumbs, a "crab claw" that was like a cheap fish cake then a bit of fish fried and some chicken for some reason. The quality just came across as cheap more akin to what you'd get from a UK freezer chain at Christmas. Again maybe a bad night as this went against the reviews listed here, we actually didn't want any more food and asked for the bill which we think may have confused the staff as they asked us if we were full - we just said we didn't want any more food.
It's a shame as we had high expectations and the waiting staff were friendly but we cannot recommend based on our meal. A couple behind us tried for a while to get the sweet menu but resorted to borrowing it from another table...
You can see from my other reviews that I am not a harsh reviewer and was truly disappointed with the experience. We've had Meze on many occasions and unfortunately this wasn't very good in our opinion.
If you own or manage The Windmill Restaurant (Anemomilos), register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.