Wandered into this place to grab a quick bite before catching the bus to the airport home. So glad we stumbled upon it. There were many locals hanging out and enjoying the fare. We had the reindeer burger and lamb sandwich (both good) and a small portion of the Icelandic fish stew (also good, though very heavy). The server was very knowledgeable and the food was reasonably priced by Icelandic standards. A very casual and laid-back place - we just grabbed a couple of stools at a high table in the bar area.
If you own or manage Icelandic Bar (Islenski Barinn), register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.