Went to Gamla Kaupfélagið a saturday evening. Wasn't full (luckily since there were 10 of us and we hadn't reserved a space). Ordered from a full menu, thought maybe the menu had a bit too many items to be good but it turned out fine. I had the Louisiana chicken strips (misspelled Luisiana in the menu) and they were excellent. Some of the others had a satay chicken salad and burgers, also good. Service friendly and quick, and prices quite OK. I'd happily eat there again.
If you own or manage Gamla Kaupfelagid, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.