Our travel agent (a company focused on luxury travel in Greece) recommended this hotel. After looking at the website, we were excited to stay in this "fashion hotel". Unfortunately, it turned out to be a huge disappointment. The rooms were very small, even compared to European standards. We asked to upgrade (we were willing to pay extra), but their top room wasn't much better than the room we were already in. I guess you pay for location with this hotel -- it's right in old town. The woman who works the front desk isn't very helpful and she hardly knew the layout of the town. She also gave us a HUGE "do not" list...don't sleep on the bed without moving the duvet, don't sleep on the bed without moving the canopy to the side, do not spill contact lens solution on the bathroom countertop, do not spill wine in the room. Give me a break! How old did she think we were?

We stayed in the Vosporus suite, which was on the second floor of the hotel (240 euros per night when we stayed in Oct 2007). It looked just like the pictures on the website, very atmospheric, not "somwhat gaudily decorated", as described in Rough Guide. Though we observed that Moroccan style draperies and beaded cushions are more susceptible to dust and wear and tear than standard hotel furnishings. Lovely views from the room. A welcoming fruit basket with a large bottle of water and very mediocre (alas) small bottle of wine. TV in bedroom and sitting room. DVD players. Information folder about local sights, restaurants. Comfortable beds and ample pillows. Robes and disposable slippers. Safe in room. The bathroom had a pretty, painted ceiling which was lit attractively, a jacuzzi and piped music. Feeble hairdryer. Limited toiletries available, and frankly not at all luxurious (as described on the hotel website). The devil is in the detail, however, and the toiletries were not replenished during our three night stay, room cleaning was cursory, laundry was poorly done, although inexpensive.
Breakfast (available 8am till noon) on our first morning was served in the courtyard. A pleasant place to sit, we were brought decent coffee, freshly squeezed orange juice, savoury and sweet pastries, bread, jam and carrot cake, and you could also order eggs or crepes. Maybe other things, like yoghurt. On our second morning it rained, and so a long table was set up in the very small sitting area beside the reception desk, where it was less tranquil, especially after the maids flung open the doors of one of the adjacent rooms (releasing a cloud of stale overnight air) and bustled about their cleaning duties, very close to where we were seated. Location would be a problem with the two downstairs rooms (Marokino and Ontas), as a previous reviewer has noted, as they are right next to the reception desk, and so could be noisy. We wondered also if there would be noise from the suites above, Vosporus and Tzami, especially when we had to leave ours very early to catch a flight. We were as quiet as we could be, but the floors are wooden, and the stairs also.
Reception staff were friendly, and efficent in answering queries and booking a hire car and airport taxi. For some reason no internet access was available for some of our stay , but there are internet cafes in the Old Town. The reception is not 24 hour, we wondered whom to contact should our very early taxi not arrive, but it did.
This wouldn't be a good choice for someone with mobility issues, as there are quite a few stairs from the street, and also stairs if you are staying in the second floor suites. It has to be said that the location is excellent, as it is very close to the Palace of the Grand Masters, and yet removed from the bustle of Old Town with its crowds and restaurant touts. We enjoyed Hatzikelis fish taverna (near St Mary's Gate), and Romios (not Romeo) restaurant, neither of which was close to Nikos Takis.
In summary, I would agree with a previous reviewer, that the hotel is not in any way special, given its price range. If we were to visit Old Town Rhodes again, we thought we would try the newly-opened Avalon, which is in a similar price range and also aspires to be a boutique hotel. We scoped out its very attractive courtyard, and it also has an excellent location close to the Palace of the Grand Masters.

Our travel agent found this hotel after we had read about it on TripAdvisor. It was, by far, the best place we stayed during our whole stay in Greece. Having never been overseas before, I was surprised by how hard the beds were, but the bed at this hotel was pure heaven.

We were greeted with wine and fruits and cheeses. The breakfast was superb on the patio. The staff was warm and helpful, always willing to offer dinner suggestions, calling for cabs, etc.

Overall, our two nights there were fabulous and it is in a great location within the Old City of Rhodes.

Eager to please and genuinely nice staff made our stay enjoyable. The hotel is located within the Old City and once you exit the hotel and turn the corner, you are greeted by the hustle and bustle of this popular port stop.

We were greeted by the staff upon our arrival and although our room was not ready, they took care of our bags as we toured the Old Town. When we returned, our bags were in the room as was a bowl of fruit, a bottle of water and a bottle of ok wine.

We stayed in the "Ontas". We loved the color scheme and decor of the room and found the bed really comfortable. The room was located next to the main reception area which is the main drawback for this room and the reason we did not rate this hotel higher. Every time we opened our main door we saw the staff or guests that were taking care of their business. It was fine at first and then it got to us a little. Also, when in your room you over hear any conversation that takes place in the lobby. Although we spent little time in our room during our four day stay, our mid afternoon naps were not as pleasurable due to the rooms location. We did get many great nights of sleep as the hoteland the lobby is very tranquil in the late hours.

I would rate it a 3 1/2 if I had the option but I don't so it gets a three. The location of the "Ontas" room is not worth the price we paid.