Just came back from "Old Ithaki". I went there with my family, because it was recommended to us by our guide, who described it as a little local restaurant. It didn't look too well from the beginning on, the place was full of tourists and the staff was too friendly for such a place... Our waiter didn't let us look at the menu, telling us that he would bring some starters and then take our order according to the kind of meat that we wanted. The starters weren't that bad, but nothing special... The main dishes were terrible, an overcooked octopus, tasteless fish and dry meat among others. The big surprise of the night was the bill, they charged us more than 20€ for every dish, including the starters; and complained about having problems with the system when we asked to pay with a credit card.
All in all, it wasn't a nice experience and i wouldn't recommend this restaurant to anyone who can avoid to go there!
If you own or manage Old Ithaki, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.