We went to this restaurant based on TripAdvisor reviews. It fully lives up to its hype - by far the best restaurant we went to in Albufeira.
It was priced around 44 Euros each for food, which is good value for what you get (it is a fixed menu, 5 courses). The drinks on the other hand are extremely expensive - we paid 27 Euros for a bottle of wine - the cheapest was about 17 Euros.
The courses were brilliant - we had (from memory) something like the following:
Course 1 - Asparagus with Smoked Salmon/Camembert with Pear & Ham
Course 2 - Soup (Red Lentil & Tomato)
Course 3 - Fish course (Hake in Saffron Sauce)
Course 4 - Fillet of Beef/Spicy Iberian Pork Fillet
Course 5 - Seasoned Strawberries/Lemon Tarte
We had two bottles of wine (52 Euros!!) to go with this, bringing the bill to around 150 Euros with a tip.
The service and venue enhance the meal - as all reviews mention, the owners are fantastic hosts, passionately explaining the menu; you really feel that they are looking after you personally. The restaurant itself is very quaint - there are only 30 covers, and you get the table for the whole night, there is no time limit.
Overall, whilst this was expensive (not for families, more for couples/groups of adults), it still felt like value for money, as the whole experience made for a great evening. Make sure you book though....(also note they don't open every night!)
If you own or manage Restaurante Dom Carlos, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.