My husband and I were married in San Gimignano in 2007, so obviously feel quite an affinity with the town. We went back this year, and just had to go back to the Vecchie Mura which was the highlight of our previous visit to San Gim (apart from the wedding thing of course!!).
The night after our wedding, we visited Le Vecchie Mura to celebrate a birthday with six friends. The eight of us ate till our bellies were full, each of us devouring a different meat :-) Our friends said they had never ate so well, and I remember feeling quite guilty when we all saw how little the final bill came to!!
This year, Le Vecchie Mura didn't disappoint. Although the heat in San Gim that day was unbearable, although we were tired from a day of sightseeing none of that mattered when my husband was presented with his plate of Ribollita - he was home. The food was as good as I remembered and the friends we were with said the steak was the best they had ever eaten.
The servers are very amiable and the decor is super modern. The best part is the outside terrace, on which you can see the valley in the distance as you eat.
This place is superb and well worth a visit if you are in the area. Go on, do it!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.