We recently had a 6-night stay at Antica Torre and couldn't have asked for more.
Our corner room was comfortable, clean, sufficiently large and had a direct view over Piazza Santa Trinita (with the duomo cupola in the background) and a partial view of the Arno.
The staff is outstanding. Everybody was extremely helpful and friendly.
Antica Torre's location is very convenient and within easy walking distance to all the important sights and the two roof top terraces are simply wonderful. At night, after the bartender is gone, it is still possible to enjoy a drink on the terrace using their honor system.
Instead of taking a taxi, we had arranged private transportation from and to the airport through the hotel and the driver was punctual, informative and very entertaining.
We highly recommend Antica Torre and will definitely stay there again next time we visit Florence.