Ended up here when the place we were after was closed. Ambience is nice, service is okay, but the food is mixed to poor. Pasta dish was interesting and passable, steak was ok quality but peppercorn sauce was somehow sweet! For dessert, torta della nonna was burnt on top, disguised with too much icing sugar.
House wine was cheap but not good at all. To be honest the food would be 3 stars in most places, but in Florence competition is tough and this is just not good enough. Everyone else here was a tourist, who probably did not know better. They seemed slightly surprised that I, as an Italian, was there. Go to one of the great places the city has to offer, not here.
If you own or manage Acqua Al 2, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.