We went to Pesce d'Oro after looking at Trip Advisor and also after a recommendation from one of the bars in Alghero. We booked that day for the evening slot, which was just as well as come evening it was packed. (We have been back since and couldn't get a table in late November!) The service was excellent, food delicious and wine recommended by our waiter was exceptional and not pricey. Excellent on all counts. There were a lot of locals eating there including other restaurant owners who were shutting up for the winter and taking their staff out. That counts as a pretty good recommendation in my book!
If you own or manage Il Pesce d'oro, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.