La Magioca was a great place to stay and the staff was great! Our hostess, in Italian only, managed to communicate warmly and make us feel at home. Breakfasts were filling and excellent. Rooms were clean and nicely decorated. Great chocolates were available in the lounge. In fact, there was always something to munch on somewhere, and their choice of Prosecco was terrific. But for a couple of issues (one specific to us), we would give La Magioca an excellent.
The specific issue was fragrances - there were cachets and fragrant items in several places in our room. Some folks won't care, but it is an issue for my allergy-prone spouse. Our bath had no shower curtain. There is a hand shower hose that's hung on the wall, but don't try to take a shower standing up - you'll get the whole bathroom wet. There are occasional events (especially weddings) that might be disruptive to a guest.
There is one fantastic restaurant just out the gate and another OK one across the road. The hotel is out in the country in the Valpolicella wine region. Verona itself is a bit of a poke and the roads are confusing, but we managed to use La Magioca as a base for exploring lakes Garda and Como, the Dolomites (Trento, Bolzano & Cortina), Bergamo, Vicenza and of course Verona.
We would definitely stay there again.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.