I found the restaurant as most other reviews describe it: very nice but informal. Everything we ate was very good, both in quality and in presentation. We paid about 40€ per person for a main course, a side order, a dessert, and two glasses of wine. Expect to add 30€ if you aim at the full three-course dinner (adding entree and pasta). I was disappointed the wine list did not offer bottles, only glasses, but to be honest I did not ask for the option. Our "business dinner" was a bit spoiled by very noisy guests at a nearby table, but that's just bad luck.
If you own or manage Ai Vicoli, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.