I have just returned from a 4 day stay in Hotel Villa San Pio. We had actually booked into one of the nearby sister hotels, Hotel Aventino (who had unlawfully deducted one night's fee from my account in JUNE with no explanation) - only to find the gate locked on arrival and a flimsy note attached advising people to go to one of the sister hotels. We went to Hotel Anselmo, only to be told to go to Villa San Pio - no explanation or apology was given for Aventino being closed and us not having been advised. In fact, the attitude was along the lines of 'what do you want here, we're a four star hotel, go down to the 3-star'. On arrival, we received similar cold and unfriendly treatment. No apology or explanation was given for the situation.
Perhaps its a taste thing, but I found the room - though a good size and with a huge balcony - quite gaudy and strangely decorated in an overly false ornate style. The breakfast was excellent. However, if you are someone who values good customer service, stay away from this hotel. The demeanour and attitude of the majority of the reception and bar/breakfast room staff was nothing short of hostile. Examples include asking for information on boat trips and the briefest of answers being given before the receptionist literally walked off; asking for change and a bag of mixed coins being emptied out onto he counter for us to fumble through.
Although some may value the peace and quiet of the neighbourhood (this was indeed why I booked it), this proved to give a false sense of security. Only around the corner from the hotel, on my second last day, I was mugged in broad daylight - money, phone, bank and credit cards and passport stolen. So you may well have a nice quiet hotel, but if you cannot step outside the door or walk into the city centre, I feel this utterly defeats the purpose. Note: no support was offered from the hotel staff in relation to this.
Incidentally, there are no shops, bar or cafe nearby, all residential, so there is nothing to do outside of the hotel at night.
I have never, ever had such a bad experience of a hotel and stayed in such an unsuitable area. The experience ruined my holiday in Italy.