We booked a tour of the Vatican Museum and St. Peter's Basilica through When in Rome Tours. Other than some Internet reviews, we went in "blind" and didn't know what to expect. It turned out great. Our tour guide, Luigi, was erudite and personable, and he offered all sorts of advice and observations that, in my opinion, went far above and beyond what is normally expected of a tour guide.
If you own or manage When In Rome Tours, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.