Stayed 4 nights in hotel after a tour of Venice, Florence and Rome. Property is very nice with large common area rooms. Note, however, that the hotel is right in the middle of the town and there is a lot of traffic/people passing by, so it is not quiet during the day. At night (around 10 pm in October) traffic subsided and we did not have a problem with noise while sleeping, but the traffic is back by 7 am.
Our room faced sea and we really enjoyed the view, as well as people watching. The room was nice with high ceiling and sufficient space, but it lacked certain accoutrements usually found at hotels in this price range, such as glass ware, complimentary water, decent pillows. It may be because Amalfi is very much a beach town compared to these other cities, and you pay up for just about everything.
Breakfast on terrace is a great setting and wonderful way to start day. Staff is very attentive and makes as many cappuccinos as you can swallow. Food at b'fast is adequate, nothing special. (For some reason they serve eggs and bacon in a warming dish but do not use anything to keep food warm.)
Front desk is efficient and friendly, and very helpful with maps, dinner suggestions, directions, etc.