The setting is really nice, and some of the food -- particularly the gratis bacon bits to start -- was outstanding. But, my roast pork didn't quite live up to the other reviews, and we didn't find the waitstaff particularly accommodating. (We had an odd experience to start: it was obvious from our entrance that we didn't speak much Spanish, and yet they brought us Spanish menus. We assumed, therefore, that they didn't have English menus -- which was fine -- and asked the folks at the table next to us if they could help us translate the menu, to which they replied, "why don't you ask them for the English menu?" I know, not a big deal, but it just showed a certain lack of caring.
So, if you're in the neighborhood, it's fine; I think there are probably better places you can go for your roast pork fix.
If you own or manage La Taberna del Capitan Alatriste, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.