This place was just around the corner from our apartment and we stopped in for dinner twice. The first time we waited approximately 45 minutes for a table and the second time we stopped in as they opened and made a reservation.
Both times it was full and there were people waiting outside from pretty early in the evening. The food is great with lots of possibilities and combinations and there is a large wine selection.
Service is good, they are busy so you'll want to be proactive about interacting with the wait staff.
Would definitely recommend a visit, we'd love to return.
If you own or manage La Tinaja, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.