My husband and I loved the Hotel America for these reasons:
LOCATION:It is right in the middle of the Alhambra which means it is a PLEASANT WALK (not hard at all) to the ticket office and grounds. The Alhambra is HUGE and it is meant to be walked. DO NOT TAKE people there who have difficulty. Ther are no trams--thank goodness. It is just as it should be.
It is right next door to the pricier Parador, so how much better of a location is possible...?... unless you build another hotel on the grounds but then where would it go? Let's hope no more hotels pop up in this heritage site, or it will become Disneyfied.
CHARMING ROOM: Our room was the top balcony room. Small but very cute with traditional Spainish touches. Anyone who has traveled Europe/UK and admires personal, charming hotels will appreciate it! Personally, we loved the cute accents like the wooden closet with the lace curtain, the lovely tiles and wood. No, this is not a LUXURY Hotel; go elsewhere for slick decor void of character. Or balance out your trips with a mix of luxury and unique character to get the best of both worlds.
Noise was not a problem for us--I am sorry for those who had this problem. I always think this is the luck of the draw--one never knows when this can happen, no matter what the quality of the hotel might be. We were in a sound-proof stone-walled castle last year--or so we thought--until I read a noise complaint on trip advisor. Luck of the draw...!
PROXIMITY TO TOWN: We walked into town. It is safe and you will get a sense of the layout, architecture, cute nooks, etc. On our two nights there, we walked to an AMAZING flamenco performance in the gypsy quarter, top tapas in the heart of the main city(no tourists except us--but the server/tender was so friendly and helpful. We had a blast!)and we found(without the aid of any guide book) an incredible restaurant. We are big foodies--having dined in the best places around the world. And I can say this is the best roasted pork ever you'll ever taste!
SERVICE: The owner of Hotel America called the above restaurant for us and without even telling us, secured for us the most special table. It overlooked the city below with no obstruction. The servers treated us like royalty--I suspect due to the Hotel's call. Again no tourists there, but there seemed to be very sophisticated, Spanish clientale at one table. Romantic couples dotted the others on the spacious terrace. So lovely!!
That was our experience at Hotel America.
We hope you have a great one, too.