Having read the good reviews I thought I would put this restaurant to the test (I have been to Berlin 4 times now and walked past this restaurant many a time on my way to/from the accommodation I stay at).
I can sum up this restaurant in a few words: expensive, poor value, average food. I had a much better meal (value and quality of food) the following night in a cafe a few streets away. They may well claim to serve unusual food but small portions + high prices = poor value. Avoid unless you have money to throw away!
If you own or manage Neugruens Koche, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.