The prices you pay here are not really worth what you get. I found the steaks to be slightly overpriced especially when a couple of them were slightly overcooked. However the burger I had was tasty enough and I enjoyed it. The fact you have to bring your own alcohol means that you can get a better wine than perhaps you'd normally pay for in a restaurant to go with your steak. This may be quite a bonus to many diners and corkage prices are reasonable too.
Service is pretty fast, although somewhat impersonal. I feel like you could be in an out of here rather quickly which is not always what you want when coming for a meal. Not sure I'd return simply based on the fact there are so many restaurants in Edinburgh to try and this one didn't impress me enough to make me want to return instead of trying elsewhere.
If you own or manage The Buffalo Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.