We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.
Free Newsletter

Interested in Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel and Edinburgh?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel and Edinburgh each week.

  • Save Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel
  • E-mail this page
BOOK NOW!

Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel: Traveler Reviews


Check Rates and Availability
mm/dd/yyyy mm/dd/yyyy
Check Rates
Find Cheap Flights to Edinburgh

Traveler Reviews

62% Recommend
3.5 of 5 stars 195 reviews
Excellent
Very good
Average
Poor
Terrible
By trip type
All (195)
[ Date ] [ Rating ]
Poor reviews are unjust

Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel

Save Review
4 of 5 stars
A TripAdvisor Member
Kearny, NJ
Jun 18, 2004
1/1 found this review helpful

My husband and I were confused at the poor reviews the Roxburghe received. We spent 6 nights in late May 2004 and everything was lovely.
Yes, the main lift was broken but anyone staying on the 4th and 5th floor where no lift was available your bags were taken up for you. If you're on vacation - walking up and down 2 flights shouldn't present a problem considering the amount of walking you'll do sighseeing. The staff was very friendly, helpful. The room was large with a king sige bed, clean and the bathroom was very large, modern and clean. The huge delicious English and continental buffet breakfast kicked off the start of each day. Centrally located, quiet. Yes, no air conditioning but many hotels in Europe do not have air conditioning and if you need AC check the hotel prior to booking. We booked through a very inexpensive travel site and we were not not given a bad room because of our low rate. A 4 - 5 star hotel in Europe is not the same as in the USA. Don't expect Trump Plaza or a Hilton. Nor is a Radisson in Europe the same in the US.

Yes, we would definitely stay here again:)

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Check Rates
Average price*: $343 (year-round)
Call now to book: 1-800-45-HOTEL from hotels.com
Excellent hotel, great location

Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel

Save Review
5 of 5 stars
A TripAdvisor Member
Preston, UK
Jun 17, 2004
1/1 found this review helpful

I made the booking via activehotels at a extremely good rate and was prepared for a substandard room, having read previous reviews on tripadvisor. However, the room was very attractive, clean and well equipped. OK, the lift wasn't working but I didn't find this too much of a problem as the directions to rooms were very clear. I found the staff very helpful and friendly and overall found the hotel excellent and in a great location. I would certainly recommend it.

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Check Rates
Average price*: $343 (year-round)
Call now to book: 1-800-45-HOTEL from hotels.com
Appalling place

Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel

Save Review
1 of 5 stars
A TripAdvisor Member
London
Jun 5, 2004
3/4 found this review helpful

An unbelievably poor hotel. The weekend I stayed the main lifts had broken down and stayed that way for 3 days. I was on the 5th Floor. The tiny backup lift only went to the 3rd floor, and from there you had to follow a poorly signposted convoluted route to the floors above. When I was lost initially, the concierge was extremely reluctant to come up and show me the way, and NONE of the nearby household staff knew how to get to the right floor from that lift!
The fridge in the room did not work, and several calls for them to fix it went unanswered. The 5th Floor also has two large terraces with inviting views but stayed locked the entire weekend. The room itself felt old and smelt of years of smoke, even though it was supposedly a non-smoking room!
In general the staff were rude or borderline incompetent. Great location, but awful hotel. Stay elsewhere.

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Check Rates
Average price*: $343 (year-round)
Call now to book: 1-800-45-HOTEL from hotels.com
Is it a Four Star Hotel?

Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel

Save Review
2 of 5 stars
mbakrania 12 contributions
London, England
Jun 3, 2004
2/5 found this review helpful

1) Our room did not have any net curtains
so people across the street can see what
your doing!

2) The hotel has no Air Conditioning! We asked for
a Fan but there were all used by other guests,
but we were very lucky to get one a few
hours later

3) The Lift wasn't working, so we had to walk
5 flights of stairs to our room, bit difficult if
you had loads to drink!

Thats about it!

  • My ratings for this hotel
    • 1 of 5 stars Value
    • 3 of 5 stars Rooms
    • 2 of 5 stars Cleanliness
    • 2 of 5 stars Service
  • Date of stay April 2004
  • Member since June 02, 2004
  • I recommend this hotel for Young singles, Older travelers, Families with young children, Families with teenagers, Tourists
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Check Rates
Average price*: $343 (year-round)
Call now to book: 1-800-45-HOTEL from hotels.com
Not impressed!

Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel

Save Review
2 of 5 stars
A TripAdvisor Member
Glasgow
Apr 20, 2004
3/3 found this review helpful

We bought a 2 night trip as a present for my parents. We joined them for lunch on the second day and could tell that they were disappointed in their room. When we went to view it we were embarrassed - it was a rather sub-standard attic room with 2 sky light windows and no view! It was clear that anyone taking up a special offer break was put in the 'sad' rooms - there certainly seemed to be much nicer ones on offer!

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Check Rates
Average price*: $343 (year-round)
Call now to book: 1-800-45-HOTEL from hotels.com
Travelers Who Viewed This Property Also Viewed
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
$239*
Check Rates
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
$260*
Check Rates
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
$261*
Check Rates
*Average price
Write Your Own Hotel Review
Been to Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel? Share your experiences!
Write a Review
Add Photos
Add Videos

Do You Own Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel?

TripAdvisor has free and easy resources to help you enhance your listing and promote your property.

  • Start Here - Visit Your Owner's Page
  • Add Photo
  • Add Video

Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel Also Known As

Address: 38 Charlotte Square, Edinburgh EH2 4HQ, Scotland