The presenter was probably one important factor why this was rated so high. She obviously did an excellent job. The cave certainly is very unusual and had a number of unanswered questions. A very nice place to visit and may attract further research into the subject later. However, it does not deserve a rating higher than the Edinburgh castle. Must book before embarking on the bus trip, even in a low season like early March. There were 2 parties who was refused entry because they did not book before hand.
If you own or manage Gilmerton Cove, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.