Stayed in the Vestry suite for a night just before our wedding. The suite was amazing, very romantic and we ate in the Secret Garden which was equally romantic. food was delicious

the next morning we chose to eat breakfast in the restaurant instead of our room and it too was beautiful. And although we were the only couple at breakfast we didnt feel awkward.

Fantastic service all round.

A must if you visit Edinburgh

After stumbling across the Witchery on the web we waited 7 months for the first available weekend and it was well worth it. We absolutely loved this place it was perfect for an intimate weekend. We stayed in The Vestry suite and adored the gothic opulence of it, if you like a swanky, contemporary 5* then this probably won't be for you but if you like sheer over the top romance then you'll love it. It's true what others have said that Edinburgh is a beautiful city but you just won't want to leave your room, we had champagne on ice, a roll top bath, red velvet everywhere and the snow falling outside - perfect. The continental breakfast that is brought to your room is more than sufficient but we tried the a la carte breakfast in the Witchery restaurant on our second morning which was excellent, I can recommend the Arnold Bennet omelette and my husband thought it was the best black pudding hehad ever had. We ate in The Secret Garden on our 2nd night which was beautiful, fantastic food in a lovely candlelit ambience (ask for a table by the window) Staff were attentive enough without being intrusive, slightly pricey yes but for something special worth every penny.If you like to experience something different try The Witchery, we'll definitely be going back!

We stayed at the witchery for our honeymoon, the stay surpassed all our expectations, can not see why anyone has published a bad word against the place. Roxy whom we had already read about showed us to our suite "the vestry" which was as he said theatrical - nothing can prepare you for the room until you see it first hand. Totally burlesque!!

We ate in the secret garden the first night (which we had booked in advance) and were so impressed we booked for our second night. Two nights is never enough in a place like this hard to imagine staying anywhere else.

Already planning our anniversary stay - absolutely fantastic

We stayed in the Inner Sanctum for one night to celebrate our honeymoon in lavish over the top surrounds. We got what we were looking for! The Witchery was so much fun, we're now determined to become ridiculously wealthy and work out some sort of permanent lease program with the hotel/restaurant.
The snacks, champagne upon arrival, room, and bathroom were all fantastic.
We had a wonderful dinner at the Witchery restaurant. The food was delicious, our waiters were all charmingly Scottish young men, and we could not have been happier. The seafood in Scotland is so fantastic! I think I'm permanently spoilt from having it in such great quantities.
One night, for us, was perfect. We got to enjoy the experience without going broke. The staff was stupendous, the breakfast brought to our room was so wonderful. All in all, it made for a very relaxing, romantic stay.
It was fun reading the guest book in our room -- there were so many cute couple stories! A lot of honeymoons and anniversaries.