I booked the Muirloch executive lodge 5 for my husband's birthday for a 3 night stay. We couldn't have been more pleased when we arrived. As we would not arrive till after reception closed they left our keys in the bar for us along with directions to the lodge. The lights were left on for us and the lodge was spacious, clean and beautiful. Just a 6 mile trip into dundee centre. The hot tub was great, plenty space for 2 people and the outside table and chairs were a welcome addition. On our second morning there we had opened the door leading to the outside as it was a beautiful day and were visited by the ducks from the local lake who had no qualms about coming inside and saying hello, even letting us pet them which was fantastic! We ate at the hotel on the Saturday night and the food was excellent, the fillet steak was one of the largest and nicest we have ever had. I know people have complained about having to take everything you need with you, including dish soap, cloths and towels but it is a self catering lodge so I understood that we would need to bring essentials with us, which I didn't see as a problem. The only gripe I had was that checkout is 10am, which seems a bit early for having breakfast, cleaning up and packing everything but other than that it was well worth the money and we will definitely be going back for an extended stay.