Voted Pemberton`s Best Pizza but Not a Pizza Joint, but they make a great Pizza. Try the Treaty Pie with Salmon & Pepper Corns. Great place to sit Outside in Summer too. It has a real Hitching Post to like the Gateway Building. People really ride up for coffee or meal & tie up their Horses.1 block from the Old Hotel, 3 & equivalent of 8 blocks from the 2 new hotels. Sometimes there is a long wait of an hour or more between ordering & meal service. Don`t go if your starving & can`t wait, or snack 1st.
If you own or manage The Pony Expresso, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.