We started with the garlic shrimp appetizer, 12 shrimp overdone in way too much butter and way too much garlic. It was literally sitting in a pool of butter.
My girlfriend had the red pepper pesto fusilli...it was incredibly bland. I had the "meat" lasagna...one thing missing...meat. There was none except for some pepperoni (?) under the cheese. The tomato sauce it came in was sweet, and tasty in comparison to my girlfriends dish...so I gave her some of my sauce.
Our waitress seemed annoyed. She practically threw our plates down on our table. When she would ask us a question we could barely answer before she was walking away. My girlfriend, being in the business, watched her to see if she did the same other tables...and she did. When time came to pay the bill, my girlfriend tipped her 15% as she did not enjoy her time there...the waitress again threw down the receipt. My girlfriend looked at me in disgust and couldn't believe she had done that. To boot, she showed another server right in front of us and complained about the "awful" gratuity. Doubt we'll be back.
If you own or manage Theo's Eatery, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.