We have been customers to Fish on 5th in Sidney, for about 10 years. We used to have dinner there once a week.......and recommended the restaurant to everyone! The food was always perfect, the place spotless, and the staff was fantastic.
We really can't say all of that anymore. Our dinners at the restaurant are very infrequent now, due to disappointment in the food quality, amount, price changes, and unfortunately the attitude and dress choices of the staff. We have been very disappointed several times. It's become expensive and not very enjoyable.
Tonight's dinner was really terrible. We paid $27+ for way-overcooked fish, and fries. The fish was "chewy" if you can picture that. The fries were hard! The coleslaw had way too much sauce in it. My tea was good, but served in that silly teapot without a lid, so the second cup is cold. The restaurant did not have that clean, good food smell to it either!
Our young lady server was the brightest spot in the dinner outing. She is brand new, and was very polite, careful to get our order right, and cheerful. I regret I didn't note her name, but she is also a lifeguard at Panorama!
Please do something to return this great place back to its "old days" quality. We will try one more time..........and if it's not improved, that'll be unhappily it for us. Sorry, Diane & Chuck
If you own or manage Fish on Fifth, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.