I have eaten here about 7 times now and have never been disappointed, nor have any of the people who attended with me. The servcie is always good. It may not be the quickest, as I have read on this web site, however, I think it is more because they don't want to rush you, or make you feel rushed. The servers are always very friendly and accomodating. They offer a great selection on their menu along with some excellent specials. And unlike some of the higher end restaurants, I have never left hungry because the portions are quite generous. The atmosphere and decor compliment the dining experience. They don't seem to be resting on their good reputation, and continue to strive to make your dining occasion a positive one. If an out-of-towner asked me to recommend one restaurant in Chatham that I knew would be good, it would be Mamma Maria's.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.