My husband and I have dined at Evans before and decided to make it the place to celebrate our anniversary this month. We called a few days ahead and requested a special table as we said we were celebrating our anniversary. When we arrived, and this was a weekday night, we were given the worst table in the restaurant closest to the kitchen noise and dishes. After about ten minutes when it appeared that the other empty tables were not reserved, we requested to be moved to a better table. They obliged and gave us a great table, but I don't know why they didn't seat us there immediately as the restaurant was not full. We ordered a bottle of our favorite wine off the wine list, only to be told that they did not have any on hand. Our dinner started out not like we envisioned and we found ourselves disappointed as we know it has been rated #1 on Trip Advisor. After they served some pate, we ordered an appetizer, salads and the rack of lamb which was very good. They did bring complimentary lemoncello after the meal. The gourmet food was great, but I couldn't give our last visit a 5-star rating. We've had nicer anniversary dinners elsewhere.
If you own or manage Evan's American Gourmet Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.